Jump to content


Photo

Provincial budgets and Royalties


2 replies to this topic

#1 TheNewTeddy

TheNewTeddy

    Calling out silly posts and ideas

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,327 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Toronto, Ontario

Posted 25 June 2012 - 03:02 AM

I collected some data from all the budget estimate documents from all 10 provinces and then began to compare them. These are my results.

Provinces
% of budget from Royalties
NL - 33.74%
SK - 27.88%
AB - 27.81%
BC - 6.93%
NB - 1.52%
NS - 1.24%
QC - 0.58%
MB - 0.26%
ON - 0.21%
PE - 0.02%

*QC - 4.71% (if Hydro revenues are counted as a royalty)


% of budget from Equlization
PE - 22.32%
NB - 19.93%
MB - 16.78%
NS - 15.12%
QC - 12.19%
ON - 3.23%



Months to pay off debt (IE if all revenue were dumped into debt repayment, how long would it take)
ON - 23
QC - 21
NS - 17
NL - 15
MB - 14
NB - 14
PE - 13
BC - 9
SK - 4
AB - (6) [AB could operate for 6 months without any revenue by dipping into it's savings account]



Interest on debt as % of the budget
QC - 11.61%
NS - 9.49%
NB - 8.20%
ON - 8.08%
PE - 6.49%
BC - 5.74%
NL - 5.59%
SK - 3.57%
MB - 2.21%
AB - 1.29% (one would presume AB has a net not gross surplus account)



Interest on debt as a % of royalty payments
PE - 36,666%
ON - 4,103%
QC - 2,129%
MB - 889%
NS - 804%
NB - 550%
BC - 84.26%
NL - 16.28%
SK - 12.71%
AB - 4.74%


Provinces that have over 2% of revenue from Royalties that collect Equilization
None

Provinces that have over 2% of revenue from Royalties that have a deficit of over 2.5% (compared to total revenue)
None

Provinces that have under 2% of revnue from Royalties that have a deficit of under 2.5%
None


List of provinces that collect over 5% of their total revenue from Royalties:
BC, AB, SK, NL

List of "have" provinces
BC, AB, SK, NL


List of provinces that collect under 2% of their total revenue from Royalties
MB, ON, QC, NB, NS, PE

List of "have not" provinces
MB, ON, QC, NB, NS, PE


I'd like to spark a discussion as to how the have-not provinces can become have provinces without royalties.

Feel free to contact me outside the forums. Add "TheNewTeddy" to Twitter, Facebook, or Hotmail to reach me!


#2 TheNewTeddy

TheNewTeddy

    Calling out silly posts and ideas

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,327 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Toronto, Ontario

Posted 26 June 2012 - 05:18 PM

Maybe a little more data to get a discussion rolling about Provinces and their Budgets?


NL
Roy - $2,224 (Royalties, in millions, mostly from Oil/NatGas)
Inc - $948 (Income Taxes)
Sal - $891 (Sales Taxes)
Crp - $724 (Corporate Taxes)
Gas - $174 (Gasoline Taxes)
Cig - $136 (Tobacco Taxes)
Can - $600 (From Canadian Govt. IE Transfers)
REV - $6,591 (Total Revenues)

Int - $362 (Debt Interest)
ssw - $825 (Social Services & Welfare)
Hth - $2,423 (Health)
Edu - $1,235 (Education)
EXP - $6,481 (Total Expenditures)

DEB - $8,129 (Total Debt)

-
-

PE
Roy - $0.3 (Other Royalty sources: Wind power, Timber)
Inc - $290
Sal - $218
Crp - $41
Gas - $43
Cig - $40
Prp - $106 (Property Taxes)
Can - $509
Equ - $337 (Equalization. Included in above figure!)
REV - $1,510

Int - $110
ssw - $93 (Note provinces report things differently...)
Hth - $542 (...Hence these numbers will vary widely...)
Edu - $229 (...from province to province)
EXP - $1,536

DEB - $1,695

-
-

NS
Roy - $110
Inc - $1,981
Sal - $1,621
Crp - $393
Gas - $253
Cig - $213
Can - $3,006
Equ - $1,342
REV - $8,877

Int - $885
ssw - $985
Hth - $3,768
Edu - $1,135
EXP - $9,336

DEB - $12,827

-
-

NB
Roy - $122
Inc - $1,317
Sal - $(forgot to grab, will edit in)
Crp - $223
Gas - $247
Cig - $150
Prp - $469
Can - $2,728
Equ - $1,597
REV - $8,013

Int - $672
ssw - $1,074
Hth - $2,585
Edu - $1,093
EXP - $8,196

DEB - $9,480

-
-

QC
Roy - $366
Hyd - $2,586 (Hydro Quebec Profits)
Inc - $18,897
Hth - $6,162 (Health Charge?)
Sal - $14,548
Crp - $4,078
Gas - $CNF (could not find)
Cig - $CNF
Can - $15,039
Equ - $7,639
REV - $62,650

Int - $7,794
ssw - $CNF
Hth - $CNF
Edu - $CNF
EXP - $67,150

DEB - $111,902

-
-

ON
Roy - $240
Inc - $25,800
Hth - $3,100 (Health Charge?)
Sal - $21,100
Crp - $10,800
Gas - $CNF
Cig - $CNF
Prp - $5,600
Can - $21,800
Equ - $3,621
REV - $112,200

Int - $9,849
ssw - $9,985
Hth - $47,090
Edu - $24,006
EXP - $121,842

DEB - $214,511

-
-

MB
Roy - $29
Inc - $2,796
Sal - $1,834
Crp - $620
Gas - $296
Cig - $256
Can - $3,599
Equ - $1,872
REV - $11,158

Int - $258
ssw - $CNF
Hth - $5,152
Edu - $2,321
EXP - $11,695

DEB - $12,837

-
-

SK
Roy - $3,148
Inc - $2,084
Sal - $1,348
Crp - $817
Gas - $508
Cig - $247
Can - $1,586
REV - $11,290

Int - $400
ssw - $852
Hth - $4,680
Edu - $1,351
EXP - $11,195

DEB - $3,783

-
-

AB
Roy - $11,198
Inc - $9,314
Crp - $4,471
Gas - $850
Cig - $925
Prp - $1,762
Can - $4,915
REV - $40,263

Int - $531
ssw - $2,556
Hth - $15,864
Edu - $6,543
EXP - $41,149

SAV - $21,653 (Savings)

-
-

BC
Roy - $2,986
Inc - $6,630
Sal - $6,101
Crp - $2,266
Gas - $937
Crb - $1,172 (carbon tax)
Cig - $652
Can - $7,257
REV - $43,101

Int - $2,516
ssw - $3,928
Hth - $17,970
Edu - $11,761
EXP - $43,869

DEB - $30,637

-
-


Next I will convert these numbers to per-capita for comparison

Edited by TheNewTeddy, 26 June 2012 - 05:20 PM.

Feel free to contact me outside the forums. Add "TheNewTeddy" to Twitter, Facebook, or Hotmail to reach me!


#3 Smallc

Smallc

    as in just a little

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 18,392 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Waterhen, Manitoba
  • Interests:Politics and Cars

Posted 26 June 2012 - 06:08 PM

Very interesting...and pretty self explanatory.



Reply to this topic