August1991

Les Misérables - in three very short paragraphs

14 posts in this topic

First, Anne Hathaway/Tom Hooper will rightly put the song ("I Dreamed A Dream") in its proper perspective and entirely change your wife's view of the Simon Cowell youtube version, and you too will wonder, as Victor Hugo intended, about life.

Second, Russell Crowe (in "Les Mis", as it is now known) can sing far better than Pierce Brosnan (in Mamma Mia). (BTW, IMHO: Crowe should have been cast as Valjean and Jackman as Javert.)

Third, this movie will certainly be in the 10 short list for Best Picture, and it may well win.

------

I saw the movie with French subtitles. They're very good, more poetic than the spoken/sung English, and I wonder whether they follow the original libretto.

Edited by August1991

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had planned on seeing this soon. Good to know that this movie is good. it looked great in the adverts. Thanks for no spoiler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought the novel to read - so having a go at it.

Russell Crowe played in a band before the big screen - no wonder there is a good review for him - I saw Anne Hathaway on SNL last night I thought she carried on well.

I love all genre of musical so it will be a pleasure for me to watch when I ready

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew it was a musical. I didn't know they sang the whole goddamn thing. Worst three hours of my filmgoing life. Yes, worse than Avatar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hated it when I saw it on Broadway, as did my daughters (the oldest was fortunate enough to fall asleep during the second half), but have heard good things about the movie - including from said daughters. Still, it's the only Broadway musical I've ever seen that I didn't like, so I'll wait until it comes out on tv to watch it. I loved the soundtrack, so I was surprised when I didn't like it. At all. Will be curious to see if I like the movie or not ..........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew it was a musical. I didn't know they sang the whole goddamn thing. Worst three hours of my filmgoing life. Yes, worse than Avatar.

Worse than Avatar? That would take some doing!

My wife and her sister wanted to see this and of course they took their mother and me. I really had no idea what I was in for and I kept waiting for the singing to stop. No such luck, but I remember thinking after the rebellion was put down, "I guess it's all over but the singing!"

However, the movie had an affect on me, it kind of stayed with me for the next day or two. I really did think about life and how it was so unfair for some but not others. Weird, but a couple of days later in Revelstoke, a native american was outside a restaurant looking to sell some art or get a ride or both. I don't usually do this but gave him some cash and later wondered how it was that his life turned out the way it did, stuck half way between Bassano and Lumby, doesn't own a car and has booze on his breath at 1 in the afternoon. I saw us as equals except for the circumstances that favored my life instead of his.

Edited by sharkman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew it was a musical. I didn't know they sang the whole goddamn thing. Worst three hours of my filmgoing life. Yes, worse than Avatar.

It's an opera, not a musical. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

However, the movie had an affect on me, it kind of stayed with me for the next day or two. I really did think about life and how it was so unfair for some but not others. Weird, but a couple of days later in Revelstoke, a native american was outside a restaurant looking to sell some art or get a ride or both. I don't usually do this but gave him some cash and later wondered how it was that his life turned out the way it did, stuck half way between Bassano and Lumby, doesn't own a car and has booze on his breath at 1 in the afternoon. I saw us as equals except for the circumstances that favored my life instead of his.

That was Victor Hugo's intent when he wrote the story, but why do I get the feeling you're kidding?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, no kidding, although I didn't particularly enjoy the movie.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I had planned on seeing this soon. Good to know that this movie is good. it looked great in the adverts. Thanks for no spoiler.
No spoiler?

The story was written over a century ago, and it is among the most endearing of Western literature. (Indeed, the movie is a crazy, fast-forward version so you may benefit from a few plot hints. Don't complain of spoilers.)

I bought the novel to read - so having a go at it.
It's a wonderful novel, a page turner. IMHO, Hugo wrote the first Block Buster, saga, multiple character, OTT novel. Victor Hugo invented the genre.

Michener, Rowlings are derivative, even Tolstoi.

-----

RB, I read the novel years ago in Sri Lanka. (In the Livre de poche edition, there are three books. I ran around Colombo desperately looking for Volume II until I happily found a bookstore with an "international" section. IOW, once you start, it's a page turner.)

PS. Reading Les Misérables in Sri Lanka was a revelation. It made me understand 1840 France, and 1960 Ceylon, better.

Edited by August1991

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

August, you can be a crusty, crusty man sometimes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

August, you can be a crusty, crusty man sometimes.

I think you can't never be too sure about your assessment based on these write ups by anonymous contributors sad.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

RB, I read the novel years ago in Sri Lanka. (In the Livre de poche edition, there are three books. I ran around Colombo desperately looking for Volume II until I happily found a bookstore with an "international" section.

Thanks August, I have a terrible affection for reading, I feel good even at the sight of the books - I will let you know of my thoughts once I sit down and have go...I got too busy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks August, I have a terrible affection for reading, I feel good even at the sight of the books - I will let you know of my thoughts once I sit down and have go...I got too busy
Affection for reading?

Hugo is the kind of writer who would use 300 words, a long paragraph, to explain a glance of a woman's eyes. And you would read further, to know.

Dickens, Tolstoi imitated Hugo.

August, you can be a crusty, crusty man sometimes.
I was once Left. Now, I'm Right. Edited by August1991

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites