Jump to content
Political Discussion Forums

The United Nations at its Finest


Recommended Posts

The U.N. is doing its usual bang-up job in maintaining international peace. Showing that they have skills beyond condemning Israel for its horrific atrocities (far worse than any occurring elsewhere) they are doing wonders saving lives and helping people. People often say that they are one-sided in their approach. Their work is simply great.

By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK and DAVID E. SANGER

CAIRO — The United Nations said Saturday that it was suspending its observer mission in Syria because of the escalating violence, the most severe blow yet to months of international efforts to negotiate a peace plan and prevent Syria’s descent into civil war.

The United Nations said the monitors would not be withdrawn from Syria, but were being locked down in Syria’s most contested cities, unable to conduct patrols. While the decision to suspend their work was made chiefly to protect the unarmed monitors, the unstated purpose appeared to be to force Russia to intervene to assure that the observers are not the targets of Syrian forces or their sympathizers. Russia has opposed Western intervention and, by some accounts, continues to arm the forces of President Bashar al-Assad.

*********************************

For President Obama, the suspension of the observers’ activities — unless it is reversed quickly — could signal the failure of the latest effort by the West to reach a diplomatic solution and ease Mr. Assad from power.

But Mr. Obama’s choices are no better than they were when the uprising in Syria began nearly a year and a half ago. A bombing campaign like the one conducted last year by NATO in Libya with strong American and Arab League support is not feasible in Syria: the battle is being waged in crowded cities, with little chance to attack the Syrian Army without the risk of high civilian casualties.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Who'd have thunk it? I express admiration for the great work the U.N. is doing and my thread is ignored?

For shame.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm sorry but did you actually expect the UN to do anything even remotely useful?

Their accomplishments bring tears to my eyes, just as much as the waving of Old Glory and the Israeli flag. The U.N. really is the best of the best.

As a result of their activities, Syria is now a model of civility and orderly freedom.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your thread was ignored because it sucks.

Why?

You can't stand my showing my support for the U.N.?

Link to post
Share on other sites
No I just find your fake sarcasm and whining about Israel boring and pathetic.
And you would deny the serious levels of Israeli atrocities? The Israeli butchery of the Dhubai athletic team at the Olympics for example? Or the IDF's practice of invading homes and plunging knives into babies?
Link to post
Share on other sites

And you would deny the serious levels of Israeli atrocities? The Israeli butchery of the Dhubai athletic team at the Olympics for example? Or the IDF's practice of invading homes and plunging knives into babies?

:lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites
Screw the UN. They do shit all other than write carefully worded statements.
We agree on that. And their statements aren't so great either.
Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Peeves

Screw the UN. They do shit all other than write carefully worded statements.

UN stands for Useless Numbnuts.

Now they're whining about the laws in Quebec that deal with the 'rights' of student protests.

Ridiculous! The laws about demonstrating at the UN are tougher than those recently endorsed in la belle province.

Link to post
Share on other sites

UN stands for Useless Numbnuts.

Now they're whining about the laws in Quebec that deal with the 'rights' of student protests.

Ridiculous! The laws about demonstrating at the UN are tougher than those recently endorsed in la belle province.

Posts on the UN go nowhere, just as does the UN.

You are denigrating the hard work and self-sacrifice of intrepid and idealistic U.N. delegates.
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 months later...

Posts on the UN go nowhere, just as does the UN.

Let me count the great works of the U.N.

  1. Peace in the Middle East;
  2. End to climate change; and
  3. Cure of the common cold

Link to post
Share on other sites

Let me count the great works of the U.N.

  1. Peace in the Middle East;
  2. End to climate change; and
  3. Cure of the common cold

Heres a few more...


  1. Maintaining peace and security - By having deployed a total of 42 peace-keeping forces and observer missions as of September 1996, the United Nations has been able to restore calm to allow the negotiating process to go forward while saving millions of people from becoming casualties of conflicts. There are presently 16 active peace-keeping forces in operation.
  2. Making peace - Since 1945, the United Nations has been credited with negotiating 172 peaceful settlements that have ended regional conflicts. Recent cases include an end to the Iran-Iraq war, the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan, and an end to the civil war in El Salvador. The United Nations has used quiet diplomacy to avert imminent wars.
  3. Promoting democracy - The United Nations has enabled people in over 45 countries to participate in free and fair elections, including those held in Cambodia, Namibia, El Salvador, Eritrea, Mozambique, Nicaragua and South Africa. It has provided electoral advice, assistance, and monitoring of results.
  4. Promoting development - The UN system has devoted more attention and resources to the promotion of the development of human skills and potentials than any other external assistance effort. The system's annual disbursements, including loans and grants, amount to more than $10 billion. The UN Development Programme (UNDP), in close cooperation with over 170 Member States and other UN agencies, designs and implements projects for agriculture, industry, education, and the environment. It supports more than 5,000 projects with a budget of $1.3 billion. It is the largest multilateral source of grant development assistance. The World Bank, at the forefront in mobilizing support for developing countries worldwide, has alone loaned $333 billion for development projects since 1946. In addition, UNICEF spends more than $800 million a year, primarily on immunization, health care, nutrition and basic education in 138 countries.
  5. Promoting human rights - Since adopting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, the United Nations has helped enact dozens of comprehensive agreements on political, civil, economic, social and cultural rights. By investigating individual complaints of human rights abuses, the UN Human Rights Commission has focused world attention on cases of torture, disappearance, and arbitrary detention and has generated international pressure to be brought on governments to improve their human rights records.
  6. Protecting the environment - The United Nations has played a vital role in fashioning a global programme designed to protect the environment. The "Earth Summit," the UN Conference on Environment and Development held in Rio de Janeiro in 1992, resulted in treaties on biodiversity and climate change, and all countries adopted "Agenda 21" - a blueprint to promote sustainable development or the concept of economic growth while protecting natural resources.
  7. Preventing nuclear proliferation - The United Nations, through the International Atomic Energy Agency, has helped minimize the threat of a nuclear war by inspecting nuclear reactors in 90 countries to ensure that nuclear materials are not diverted for military purposes.
  8. Promoting self determination and independence - The United Nations has played a role in bringing about independence in countries that are now among its Member States.
  9. Strengthening international law - Over 300 international treaties, on topics as varied as human rights conventions to agreements on the use of outer space and seabed, have been enacted through the efforts of the United Nations.
  10. Handing down judicial settlements of major international disputes - By giving judgments and advisory opinions, the International Court of Justice has helped settle international disputes involving territorial issues, non-interference in the internal affairs of States, diplomatic relations, hostage-taking, the right of asylum, rights of passage and economic rights.
  11. Ending apartheid in South Africa - By imposing measures ranging from an arms embargo to a convention against segregated sporting events, the United Nations was a major factor in bringing about the downfall of the apartheid system, which the General Assembly called "a crime against humanity." Elections were held in April 1994 in which all South Africans were allowed to participate on an equal basis, followed by the establishment of a majority government.
  12. Providing humanitarian aid to victims of conflict - More than 30 million refugees fleeing war, famine or persecution have received aid from the UN High Commissioner for Refugees since 1951 in a continuing effort coordinated by the United Nations that often involves other agencies. There are more than 19 million refugees, mostly women and children, who are receiving food, shelter, medical aid, education and repatriation assistance.
  13. Aiding Palestinian refugees - Since 1950, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) has sustained four generations of Palestinians with free schooling, essential health care, relief assistance and key social services virtually without interruption. There are 2.9 million refugees in the Middle East served by UNRWA.
  14. Alleviating chronic hunger and rural poverty in developing countries - The International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) has developed a system of providing credit, often in very small amounts, for the poorest and most marginalised groups that has benefited over 230 million people in nearly 100 developing countries.
  15. Focusing on African development - For the United Nations, Africa continues to be the highest priority. In 1986, the United Nations convened a special session to drum up international support for African economic recovery and development. The United Nations also has instituted a system-wide task force to ensure that commitments made by the international community are honoured and challenges met. The Africa Project Development Facility has helped entrepreneurs in 25 countries to find financing for new enterprises. The Facility has completed 130 projects which represent investments of $233 million and the creation of 13,000 new jobs. It is expected that these new enterprises will either earn or save some $131 million in foreign exchange annually.
  16. Promoting women's rights - A long term objective of the United Nations has been to improve the lives of women and to empower women to have greater control over their lives. Several conferences during the UN-sponsored International Women's Decade set an agenda for the advancement of women and women's rights for the rest of the century. The UN Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) and the International Research and Training Institute for the Advancement of Women (INSTRAW) have supported programmes and projects to improve the quality of life for women in over 100 countries. They include credit and training, access to new food-production technologies and marketing opportunities, and other means of promoting women's work.
  17. Providing safe drinking water - UN agencies have worked to make safe drinking water available to 1.3 billion people in rural areas during the last decade.
  18. Eradicating smallpox - A 13-year effort by the World Health Organization resulted in the complete eradication of smallpox from the planet in 1980. The eradication has saved an estimated $1 billion a year in vaccination and monitoring, almost three times the cost of eliminating the scourge itself. WHO also helped wipe out polio from the Western hemisphere, with global eradication expected by the year 2000.
  19. Pressing for universal immunization - Polio, tetanus, measles, whooping cough, diphtheria and tuberculosis still kill more than eight million children each year. In 1974, only 5 per cent of children in developing countries were immunized against these diseases. Today, as a result of the efforts of UNICEF and WHO, there is an 80 per cent immunization rate, saving the lives of more than 3 million childrean each year.
  20. Reducing child mortality rates - Through oral rehydration therapy, water and sanitation and other health and nutrition measures undertaken by UN agencies, child mortality rates in the developing countries have been halved since 1960, increasing the life expectancy from 37 to 67 years.
  21. Fighting parasitic diseases - Efforts by UN agencies in North Africa to eliminate the dreaded screw worm, a parasite that feeds on human and animal flesh, prevented the spread of the parasite, which is carried by flies, to Egypt, Tunisia, sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. A WHO programme also has saved the lives of 7 million children from going blind from the river blindness and rescued many others from guinea worm and other tropical diseases.
  22. Promoting investment in developing countries - The United Nations, through the efforts of the UN Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), has served as a "match-maker" for North-South, South-South and East-West investment, promoting entrepreneurship and self-reliance, industrial cooperation and technology transfer and cost-effective, ecologically-sensitive industry.
  23. Orienting economic policy toward social need - Many UN agencies have emphasized the need to take account of human needs in determining economic adjustment and restructuring policies and programmes, including measures to safeguard the poor, especially in areas of health and education, and "debt swaps for children."
  24. Reducing the effects of natural disasters - The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) has spared millions of people from the calamitous effects of both natural and man-made disasters. Its early warning system, which utilizes thousands of surface monitors as well as satellites, has provided information for the dispersal of oil spills and has predicted long-term droughts. The system has allowed for the efficient distribution of food aid to drought regions, such as southern Africa in 1992.
  25. Providing food to victims of emergencies - Over two million tons of food are distributed each year by the World Food Programme (WFP). Nearly 30 million people facing acute food shortages in 36 countries benefited from this assistance in 1994.
  26. Clearing land mines - The United Nations is leading an international effort to clear land mines from former battlefields in Afghanistan, Angola, Cambodia, El Salvador, Mozambique, Rwanda and Somalia that still kill and maim thousands of innocent people every year.
  27. Protecting the ozone layer - The UN Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) have been instrumental in highlighting the damage caused to the earth's ozone layer. As a result of a treaty, known as the Montreal Protocol, there has been a global effort to reduce chemical emissions of substances that have caused the depletion of the ozone layer. The effort will spare millions of people from the increased risk of contracting cancer due to additional exposure to ultraviolet radiation.
  28. Curbing global warming - Through the Global Environment Facility, countries have contributed substantial resources to curb conditions that cause global warming. Increasing emissions from burning fossil fuels and changes in land use patterns have led to a build-up of gases in the atmosphere, which experts believe can lead to a warming of the Earth's temperature.
  29. Preventing over-fishing - The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) monitors marine fishery production and issues alerts to prevent damage due to over-fishing.
  30. Limiting deforestation and promoting sustainable forestry development - FAO, UNDP and the World Bank, through a Tropical Forests Action Programme, have formulated and carried out forestry action plans in 90 countries.
  31. Cleaning up pollution - UNEP led a major effort to clean up the Mediterranean Sea. It encouraged adversaries such as Syria and Israel, Turkey and Greece to work together to clean up beaches. As a result, more than 50 per cent of the previously polluted beaches are now usable.
  32. Protecting consumers' health - To ensure the safety of food sold in the market place, UN agencies have established standards for over 200 food commodities and safety limits for more than 3,000 food containers.
  33. Reducing fertility rates - The UN Population Fund (UNFPA), through its family planning programmes, has enabled people to make informed choices, and consequently given families, and especially women, greater control over their lives. As a result, women in devloping countries are having fewer children - from six births per woman in the 1960s to 3.5 today. In the 1960s, only 10 per cent of the world's families were using effective methods of family planning. The number now stands at 55 per cent.
  34. Fighting drug abuse - The UN International Drug Control Programme (UNDCP) has worked to reduce demand for illicit drugs, suppress drug trafficking, and has helped farmers to reduce their economic reliance on growing narcotic crops by shifting farm production toward other dependable sources of income.
  35. Improving global trade relations - The UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has worked to obtain special trade preferences for developing countries to export their products to developed countries. It has also negotiated international commodities agreements to ensure fair prices for developing countries. And through the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), which has now been supplanted by the World Trade Organization (WTO), the United Nations has supported trade liberalization, that will increase economic development opportunities in developing countries.
  36. Promoting economic reform - Together with the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, the United Nations has helped many countries improve their economic management, offered training for government finance officials, and provided financial assistance to countries experiencing temporary balance of payment difficulties.
  37. Promoting worker rights - The International Labour Organization (ILO) has worked to guarantee freedom of the right to association, the right to organize, collective bargaining, the rights of indigenous and tribal peoples, promote employment and equal remuneration and has sought to eliminate discrimination and child labour. And by setting safety standards, ILO has helped reduce the toll of work-related accidents.
  38. Introducing improved agricultural techniques and reducing costs - With assistance from the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) that has resulted in improved crop yields, Asian rice farmers have saved $12 million on pesticides and governments over $150 million a year in pesticide subsidies.
  39. Promoting stability and order in the world's oceans - Through three international conferences, the third lasting more than nine years, the United Nations has spearheaded an international effort to promote a comprehensive global agreement for the protection, preservation and peaceful development of the oceans. The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, which came into force in 1994, lays down rules for the determination of national maritime jurisdiction, navigation on the high seas, rights and duties of coastal and other states, obligation to protect and preserve the marine environment, cooperation in the conduct of marine scientific research and preservation of living resources.
  40. Improving air and sea travel - UN agencies have been responsible for setting safety standards for sea and air travel. The efforts of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) have contributed to making air travel the safest mode of transportation. To wit: In 1947, when nine million travelled, 590 were killed in aircraft accidents; in 1993 the number of deaths was 936 out of the 1.2 billion airline passengers. Over the last two decades, pollution from tankers has been reduced by as much as 60 per cent thanks to the work of the International Maritime Organization (IMO).
  41. Protecting intellectual property - The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) provides protection for new inventions and maintains a register of nearly 3 million national trademarks. Through treaties, it also protects the works of artists, composers and authors world-wide. WIPO's work makes it easier and less costly for individuals and enterprises to enforce their property rights. It also broadens the opportunity to distribute new ideas and products without relinquishing control over the property rights.
  42. Promoting the free flow of information - To allow all people to obtain information that is free of censorship and culturally unbiased, UNESCO has provided aid to develop and strengthen communication systems, established news agencies and supported an independent press.
  43. Improving global communications - The Universal Postal Union (UPU) has maintained and regulated international mail delivery. The International Telecommunications Union (ITU) has coordinated use of the radio spectrum, promoted cooperation in assigning positions for stationary satellites, and established international standards for communications, thereby ensuring the unfeterred flow of information around the globe.
  44. Empowering the voiceless - UN-sponsored international years and conferences have caused governments to recognize the needs and contributions of groups usually excluded from decision-making, such as the aging, children, youth, homeless, indigenous and disabled people.
  45. Establishing "children as a zone of peace" - From El Salvador to Lebanon, Sudan to former Yugoslavia, UNICEF pioneered the establishment of "Days of Tranquillity" and the opening of "Corridors of Peace" to provide vaccines and other assistance desperately needed by children caught in armed conflict.
  46. Generating worldwide commitment in support of the needs of children - Through UNICEF's efforts, the Convention on the Rights of the Child entered into force as international law in 1990 and has become law in 166 countries by the end of September 1994; following the 1990 World Summit for Children convened by UNICEF, more than 150 governments have committed to reaching over 20 specific measurable goals to radically improve children's lives by the year 2000.
  47. Improving education in developing countries - As a direct result of the efforts of UN agencies, over 60 per cent of adults in developing countries can now read and write, and 90 per cent of children in these countries attend school.
  48. Improving literacy for women - Programmes aimed at promoting education and advancement for women helped raise the female literacy rate in developing countries from 36 per cent in 1970 to 56 per cent in 1990.
  49. Safeguarding and preserving historic cultural and architectural sites - Ancient monuments in 81 countries including Greece, Egypt, Italy, Indonesia and Cambodia, have been protected through the efforts of UNESCO, and international conventions have been adopted to preserve cultural property.
  50. Facilitating academic and cultural exchanges - The United Nations, through UNESCO and the United Nations University (UNU), have encouraged scholarly and scientific cooperation, networking of institutions and promotion of cultural expressions, including those of minorities and indigenous people.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Heres a few more...

Maintaining peace and security - By having deployed a total of 42 peace-keeping forces and observer missions as of September 1996, the United Nations has been able to restore calm to allow the negotiating process to go forward while saving millions of people from becoming casualties of conflicts. There are presently 16 active peace-keeping forces in operation.

Peacekeeping missions like the one in Lebanon, for example, which stood idly by while terrorists set up their rocket launch sites nearby, or even passed information to them?

  • Making peace - Since 1945, the United Nations has been credited with negotiating 172 peaceful settlements that have ended regional conflicts. Recent cases include an end to the Iran-Iraq war, the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan, and an end to the civil war in El Salvador. The United Nations has used quiet diplomacy to avert imminent wars.
    Being "credited" with something is a far cry from having actually done it. Who credited the UN for each of these 172 settlements?
  • Promoting democracy - The United Nations has enabled people in over 45 countries to participate in free and fair elections, including those held in Cambodia, Namibia, El Salvador, Eritrea, Mozambique, Nicaragua and South Africa. It has provided electoral advice, assistance, and monitoring of results.
    At the same time, it has empowered dictators and theocracies, by giving them legitimacy and an equal voice on the world stage.
  • Promoting development - The UN system has devoted more attention and resources to the promotion of the development of human skills and potentials than any other external assistance effort. The system's annual disbursements, including loans and grants, amount to more than $10 billion. The UN Development Programme (UNDP), in close cooperation with over 170 Member States and other UN agencies, designs and implements projects for agriculture, industry, education, and the environment. It supports more than 5,000 projects with a budget of $1.3 billion. It is the largest multilateral source of grant development assistance. The World Bank, at the forefront in mobilizing support for developing countries worldwide, has alone loaned $333 billion for development projects since 1946. In addition, UNICEF spends more than $800 million a year, primarily on immunization, health care, nutrition and basic education in 138 countries.
    Big deal. Similar things are done better and more effectively by private charities, such as the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation for example.
  • Promoting human rights - Since adopting the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948, the United Nations has helped enact dozens of comprehensive agreements on political, civil, economic, social and cultural rights. By investigating individual complaints of human rights abuses, the UN Human Rights Commission has focused world attention on cases of torture, disappearance, and arbitrary detention and has generated international pressure to be brought on governments to improve their human rights records.
    Human rights like declaring that "Zionism" is a racist ideology and thus effectively denying Israel's right to exist? Protecting human rights by not-including anti-Semitism in its anti-racism resolution because "Jews are not a race" but also not including it in its resolution against religious discrimination because "Jews aren't only a religion"?
  • Protecting the environment - The United Nations has played a vital role in fashioning a global programme designed to protect the environment. The "Earth Summit," the UN Conference on Environment and Development held in Rio de Janeiro in 1992, resulted in treaties on biodiversity and climate change, and all countries adopted "Agenda 21" - a blueprint to promote sustainable development or the concept of economic growth while protecting natural resources.
    The UN's efforts to protect the environment have failed, if one listens to environmentalists today and the predictions of the effects of climate change.
  • Preventing nuclear proliferation - The United Nations, through the International Atomic Energy Agency, has helped minimize the threat of a nuclear war by inspecting nuclear reactors in 90 countries to ensure that nuclear materials are not diverted for military purposes.
    And yet, there are now a multitude of nations who possess nuclear weapons besides the 5 official UN nuclear weapon states. The UN's anti-proliferation efforts have failed. In fact, Israel probably has done more for anti-proliferation itself than the entire UN has, by destroying nuclear facilities in Iraq and Syria.
  • Strengthening international law - Over 300 international treaties, on topics as varied as human rights conventions to agreements on the use of outer space and seabed, have been enacted through the efforts of the United Nations.
    Many of these laws being deeply flawed, or even if not flawed, then usually unenforced.
  • Ending apartheid in South Africa - By imposing measures ranging from an arms embargo to a convention against segregated sporting events, the United Nations was a major factor in bringing about the downfall of the apartheid system, which the General Assembly called "a crime against humanity." Elections were held in April 1994 in which all South Africans were allowed to participate on an equal basis, followed by the establishment of a majority government.
    You really want to give credit for that to the UN? Besides, one need only look at South Africa today to see how well that's turning out.
  • Providing humanitarian aid to victims of conflict - More than 30 million refugees fleeing war, famine or persecution have received aid from the UN High Commissioner for Refugees since 1951 in a continuing effort coordinated by the United Nations that often involves other agencies. There are more than 19 million refugees, mostly women and children, who are receiving food, shelter, medical aid, education and repatriation assistance.
    Refugees like the millions of Palestinians? People who should get up on their own two feet and do something for themselves rather than waiting for handouts.
  • Aiding Palestinian refugees - Since 1950, the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) has sustained four generations of Palestinians with free schooling, essential health care, relief assistance and key social services virtually without interruption. There are 2.9 million refugees in the Middle East served by UNRWA.
    As if that even deserves its own line item. Why do the Palestinians deserve "free schooling, key social services, etc" are the expense of the rest of the world? When you are four generations removed from something, no, you're not a refugee any more.
  • Focusing on African development - For the United Nations, Africa continues to be the highest priority. In 1986, the United Nations convened a special session to drum up international support for African economic recovery and development. The United Nations also has instituted a system-wide task force to ensure that commitments made by the international community are honoured and challenges met. The Africa Project Development Facility has helped entrepreneurs in 25 countries to find financing for new enterprises. The Facility has completed 130 projects which represent investments of $233 million and the creation of 13,000 new jobs. It is expected that these new enterprises will either earn or save some $131 million in foreign exchange annually.

Just more of the "white man" meddling with Africa when it is best left alone to develop naturally.

  • Promoting women's rights - A long term objective of the United Nations has been to improve the lives of women and to empower women to have greater control over their lives. Several conferences during the UN-sponsored International Women's Decade set an agenda for the advancement of women and women's rights for the rest of the century. The UN Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) and the International Research and Training Institute for the Advancement of Women (INSTRAW) have supported programmes and projects to improve the quality of life for women in over 100 countries. They include credit and training, access to new food-production technologies and marketing opportunities, and other means of promoting women's work.
    And yet Iran sits (or recently sat, dunno if they still do) on the committe for women's rights. Laughable.
  • Reducing child mortality rates - Through oral rehydration therapy, water and sanitation and other health and nutrition measures undertaken by UN agencies, child mortality rates in the developing countries have been halved since 1960, increasing the life expectancy from 37 to 67 years.
    Admirable at first glance, but only worsens the problem of populations in these areas spiraling out of control and making them ever more dependant on further UN aid.
  • Promoting investment in developing countries - The United Nations, through the efforts of the UN Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), has served as a "match-maker" for North-South, South-South and East-West investment, promoting entrepreneurship and self-reliance, industrial cooperation and technology transfer and cost-effective, ecologically-sensitive industry.
    Pales in comparison to the investment put in by private enterprise.
  • Orienting economic policy toward social need - Many UN agencies have emphasized the need to take account of human needs in determining economic adjustment and restructuring policies and programmes, including measures to safeguard the poor, especially in areas of health and education, and "debt swaps for children."
    Economic policy should not be oriented toward "social need"
  • Curbing global warming - Through the Global Environment Facility, countries have contributed substantial resources to curb conditions that cause global warming. Increasing emissions from burning fossil fuels and changes in land use patterns have led to a build-up of gases in the atmosphere, which experts believe can lead to a warming of the Earth's temperature.

This effort has largely failed as the CO2 concentration continues to go up, and developing nations are putting out more and more greenhouse gases.

  • Preventing over-fishing - The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) monitors marine fishery production and issues alerts to prevent damage due to over-fishing.
    And yet many fish stocks are disappearing anyway.

I could go on for most of the rest of your list, or more in detail on the above, but why bother? Your list makes it sound "impressive" but one need only take a quick look at this list of accomplishments to see they are either:

1) mis-attributed to the UN

2) not actually accomplished

3) not a good idea to begin with

4) dwarfed by the efforts of private or national entities

Edited by Bonam
Link to post
Share on other sites
I could go on for most of the rest of your list, or more in detail on the above, but why bother? Your list makes it sound "impressive" but one need only take a quick look at this list of accomplishments to see they are either:

1) mis-attributed to the UN

2) not actually accomplished

3) not a good idea to begin with

4) dwarfed by the efforts of private or national entities

Those might be your opinions. I personally think you did a shitty job with almost all the ones you did address, and I dont think you or the other UN bashers has any idea of what the institution even does. People generally just judge the UN on a few high profile accounts, but the reality is that they have done a lot of usefull stuff.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Those might be your opinions. I personally think you did a shitty job with almost all the ones you did address, and I dont think you or the other UN bashers has any idea of what the institution even does. People generally just judge the UN on a few high profile accounts, but the reality is that they have done a lot of usefull stuff.

I was quick and hasty. I'm not exactly gonna spend my time researching to do an A+ job of refuting 50 separate claims, my time isn't free. A quick sentence or two off the top of my head on ~10 of the points is good enough. If you disagree, fine.

Next, the UN has done some useful stuff here and there, they've also been ineffectual and harmful in other cases. Of the positive uncontroversial activities that the UN does, there is no reason they cannot be done by private entities, and indeed there are many such entities that work in parallel with UN organizations, often more effectively.

When it comes to contentious issues, like for example the conflict in Syria, the UN is entirely ineffective and, frankly, farcical. It has no credibility at all. Just like the League of Nations before it, the UN was a nice idea, that is failing in practice.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I was quick and hasty. I'm not exactly gonna spend my time researching to do an A+ job of refuting 50 separate claims, my time isn't free. A quick sentence or two off the top of my head on ~10 of the points is good enough. If you disagree, fine.

Next, the UN has done some useful stuff here and there, they've also been ineffectual and harmful in other cases. Of the positive uncontroversial activities that the UN does, there is no reason they cannot be done by private entities, and indeed there are many such entities that work in parallel with UN organizations, often more effectively.

When it comes to contentious issues, like for example the conflict in Syria, the UN is entirely ineffective and, frankly, farcical. It has no credibility at all. Just like the League of Nations before it, the UN was a nice idea, that is failing in practice.

Of the positive uncontroversial activities that the UN does, there is no reason they cannot be done by private entities, and indeed there are many such entities that work in parallel with UN organizations, often more effectively.

Not sure how private entities are gonna do much of what the UN does. Its basically a forum for signing treaties between countries on pretty much every issue imaginable.

When it comes to contentious issues, like for example the conflict in Syria, the UN is entirely ineffective

The UN is only as good as its member states. Its simply a forum for them to collaborate. In the case of Syria theres not much political will among member states to intervene because the rebels are basically islamic terrorists that would be just as bad as Assad.

Blaming the UN for countries not acting on a security issue like Syria would be like you and I doing a phonecall to discuss something and blaming the phone because we couldnt agree on what to do.

Edited by dre
Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure how private entities are gonna do much of what the UN does. Its basically a forum for signing treaties between countries on pretty much every issue imaginable.

I was talking about the "uncontroversial" and "beneficial" part of the UN's activities, you know, charities and whatnot. The "signiging treaties between countries" part is pretty much a fiasco.

The UN is only as good as its member states. Its simply a forum for them to collaborate. In the case of Syria theres not much political will among member states to intervene because the rebels are basically islamic terrorists that would be just as bad as Assad.

Yeah and when the member states or some groups thereof (like NATO) want to act, they do so anyway, regardless of the UN. Again, ineffectual.

Blaming the UN for countries not acting on a security issue like Syria would be like you and I do a phonecall to discuss something and blaming the phone because we couldnt agree.

Sometimes the phone is the wrong medium. Sometimes an in person meeting would work better, or an email. The UN is the wrong medium.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The UN is the wrong medium.

Youve provided nothing at all to back up that opinion, and you dont seem to have a better idea.

The "signiging treaties between countries" part is pretty much a fiasco.

You couldnt name 5% of those treaties without google, and youve never read a single one of them. Youve decided the "UN is bad" but you dont seem to know much about what it does.

Im not sayings its perfect. As I said before its only as good as its member states and the ability to reach consensus on any single issue. Maybe they cant agree on attacking Syria, but they might be able to agree on international standards for shipping or aviation, or intellectual property rights.

Youre blaming the table people are sitting around for what those people do, all the while ignoring the vast majority of what they do..

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Announcements



  • Tell a friend

    Love Political Discussion Forums? Tell a friend!
×
×
  • Create New...