Jump to content
Political Discussion Forums

Is Canada (still) a democracy?

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, dialamah said:

Most Canadians agree that Canada has had reasonably good leadership throughout the pandemic, even if "could have better" is acknowledged.  What kind of democracy would it be if a minority of malcontents forced elections for everything they didn't happen to like?

You're entirely correct that it's the citizens who define and decide what democracy they will have (or not). And if the citizens wouldn't hold their governments and officials responsible, they will only hear more of "travel from Wuhan not a problem!" and "don't have to answer that". And why not, wouldn't it be only logical?

Edited by myata
Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, myata said:

Which are those most countries we're far ahead of? Shouldn't we know them by now? Maybe Tanzania? Or Ukraine? Let's see:

Maybe you would if you weren't so set in seeing Canada as the worst.  

12 minutes ago, myata said:

So where are those democratic, non-third-world countries "we're still far ahead of"? Do they exist?

Since you seem to want to claim that Canada isn't a democracy (in two threads that I know of), why do you decide to exclude non-democracies?  Anyway, I don't know and am not going to research it right now.  If you want to prove that Canada is the worst, making it a failed democracy, you can look it up and present your evidence.

As it happens, late in 2020, claims that Canada wouldn't be done till mid-2022 were rampant; now it looks like September of 2021 - assuming producers continue to supply the vaccine as promised.  So whatever the situation today, it could be better or worse tomorrow or next week.   

To posit that a moment in time of a changing situation defines Canada as democratic, or not, is a bit silly, imo.

Link to post
Share on other sites
39 minutes ago, dialamah said:

If you want to prove that Canada is the worst, making it a failed democracy, you can look it up and present your evidence.

The evidence was presented and I did take time and effort to find it. If you don't care to see it, it's not really my problem. And while we're at it, it's a fact that it took the great and independent Canadian media eight days to even notice the matter of concerns with one of the vaccines. Just in case, here's information from the Norway Ministry of Health available to Norwegians TODAY. Will Canadians have it ever - I don't know. Do you?

See, these aren't just abstract matters of successes and indexes and they can have very real, measurable cost in the numbers. And the numbers are facts, and facts do not lie, whatever we desired to dream ourselves.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By myata
      Some interesting results from the analysis of participants in the events leading to inauguration of J. Biden in this BBC story: Capitol riots: Five takeaways from the arrests.
      No, the core of the mob that stormed the Capitol were not extreme right wingers. No, it was not only (and mostly not) "redneck" counties.
      It was a much broader and diverse crowd, as stated in the article: "What we are dealing with here is not merely a mix of right-wing organisations, but a broader mass movement with violence at its core," wrote Dr Robert Pape, director of the Chicago Project on Security & Threats.
      And that is a clear symptom of a growing disenchantment and disengagement in the society with the formal democracy, a democracy from top down, by the enlightened and prosperous elites to the little people below. A democracy that lectures and preaches and never forgets itself, rather than engages, works, and achieves the results for everybody in the society.
      Almost daily, before developing a habit of instantly turning the thing off or switching the channel we could see expert heads nodding in a wonderful consensus to whatever new non-policy of the day was proposed. Lecturing. Preaching, yes we sailed all the high seas just do this and that you lowly people. And it shows in the results, doesn't it: in Covid impact the country is doing worse than Ukraine (GDP per capita around $3000) and some provinces, same as Sweden that from day one chose clear information based approach with no mandated policies. And please go and check the charts on SARS and MERS two decades earlier.
      But try asking a specific question, where is this coming from? And that published result here, what would it mean, for the policy? "Oh-this-is-still-so-new-to-us-and-so-much-we-dont-know". Wait, what about sailed all seas? Was it in the same story?
      See, there remains no avenues, no forums and no ways to discuss, openly honestly and meaningfully issues and questions of concern to the society, and to some groups in the society. Only the default, block, square brick answer, "travel from Wuhan, not a problem!" and "in it together!". Been there, sailed all seas. And after discussing we would have to take it to the reality, make a meaningful change, make it happen. Nope, not gonna happen. Need $1.5 trillion, and a decade(s)-long action plan. "Such a can of worms!".
      Now, what would it tell us about the prospects of our democracy here, for the next 160 years? Would it reveal to us anything worthy of our interest? And would we be interested to observe, think and act?
    • By sillywalker
      We the people of Canada DEMAND change in Government. 
          We the people of Canada demand that the government that belongs to us and to whom we lend our democratic power to lead this country and to sit in opposition, change the laws that govern the behaviour of those politicians that take the oath of office. 
         We are tired of the way that parties spend our hard-earned tax dollars on things that do not benefit this country. We are tired of the lies by all parties and we are tired of the personal agendas that you all bring into the house of commons instead of working toward the common goal of bettering this great nation. 
         We are tired of the ethics violations, the misappropriation of money that does not belong to you and the way you spend on other countries while here in Canada our own go without. We are tired of the way Canadians are left out in the cold as soon as you take office and the opposition all of a sudden becomes sanctimonious in the way they say they want to save us. We are tired of the Pandering politicians on all sides. We are tired of the insider trading. We are tired of the wealthy being the ones that you listen to and not us average Canadians because in fact most of you have never worked a solid day in your life. 
         We are Tired of the way that the people we elect as our Members of Parliament stop speaking for us the moment  they are told to tow the party line. We are tired of the way the country gets ignored because as soon as you take power and the house sits you then worry about the next election rather than worrying about us the people.  
         We demand change and we have some changes we want: 
         1.  We the people demand, not ask, that recall be brought into law. 
         2.  We the people demand that restricted parliamentary privilege be restricted to times that it is a benefit to the country not the politicians. 
         3.  We demand that under conditions that regular Canadians would lose their jobs that the same apply to politicians in the same fast manor. 
         4. We demand that if fired there is an end of your pension no if ands or buts. 
         5. We demand that any financial penalties that politicians receive be proportional to the wages they earn so as to sting them as we the citizens get stung. 
         6.We the people demand that when a politician ends his term that he not use political influence to enrich himself or family, if they do they are to be prosecuted. 
         7. We demand that all monies earned by the writing of books or speaking engagements by any serving politician or politician that has served (because they were only in that position to serve the country) should be paid to charity. 
         8. We demand that any politician caught deliberately lying to the citizens of this country be removed from office immediately. 
         9. We demand that any politician working against the people of this country be removed from office and if deemed serious enough be charged in a court of law. 
          These demands are put before you by citizens of all political parties, All genders and all races. 
       We the citizens of Canada have had enough of governments dividing the peoples and spending recklessly so as to force our taxes to a level that makes it hard to support our families. 
               Go to change.org to sign this petition called
                We the people of Canada DEMAND change in Government.               
  • Tell a friend

    Love Political Discussion Forums? Tell a friend!
  • Create New...